Multiple hot dogs with a variety of toppings. (Eat This, Not That!)


A divisive debate about the category of a hot dog resurfaces every few months. Is a hot dog a sandwich, or does it fall into its own category? There is a quiz that can be taken to determine individual sandwich categorization that offers a personal score. Celebrity Brie Larson recently asked her followers their opinion in a poll, which determined that hot dogs are not a sandwich. 

Sandwich believers state that a “sandwich is anything in between bread” and critics say a hot dog is cylindrical meat that deserves its own category. The National Hot Dog and Sausage Council has stated that a hot dog is not a sandwich, although the hot dog has historically been referred to as a “Coney Island Sandwich” or “Frankfurter sandwich.” The dictionary defines a hot dog as a sandwich, and New York City taxes hot dogs under a “sandwich tax.” Further rattling food connoisseurs is the Cube Rule, which classifies a hot dog as a taco

qualifying list of what makes a sandwich a sandwich includes: two exterior separated (or almost separated) pieces which are primarily carbohydrate-based, rests horizontally, and is portable. These criteria would disqualify a hot dog from being a sandwich because it fails the third criterion of resting horizontally. However, the list also disqualifies a lobster roll, gyro, and “open-faced” sandwich, all of which are commonly accepted as sandwiches. Many people would also argue that a hot dog is just a hot dog.


It’s time to stop debating whether a hot dog is a sandwich – The Verge – 4/9/2020
Few questions are as divisive as the hot dog/sandwich debate. I’ve certainly had it more times than I can count. But what’s unique about the controversy isn’t how eager people are to argue; it’s how dead-set they are in their opinions from the get-go.

A Hot Dog Is Not a Sandwich – The Atlantic – 11/5/2015
Things that are not sandwiches, however, include the wrap, the burrito, the taco, the KFC Double Down, the drastically misnamed open-faced “sandwich”… and, yes, the hot dog.

A hot dog is a taco. A steak is a salad. A Pop-Tart is a calzone. Let the Cube Rule explain. – The Washington Post – 12/12/2018
Some say that a sandwich is anything in between bread, which would make a hot dog a sandwich. But some say bread that is not in two distinct slices is different — and that tubular meat within it deserves its own distinct category.

End of debate: A hot dog is a sandwich – Washington Examiner – 8/10/2019
Whatever one associates with the simple comfort food, one thing is certain: A hot dog is and should be considered a sandwich. It is necessary to look at both history and economics to understand why the debate over hot dog categorization is a tragic illustration of governmental manipulation.


Steven Ray Morris on Twitter, 06/11/20 Nobody has presented a compelling reason why a hot dog ISN’T a sandwich. 

John Hodgman on Twitter, 6/11/20 And obviously a hot dog is not a sandwich. 

Chris Towers on Twitter, 6/11/20 I’m sorry, but if we live in a world where a lobster roll or pita are sandwiches, then a hot dog and taco are too.

Meg Graham on Twitter, 6/11/20 is the hot dog’s absence from the encyclopedia of sandwiches our definitive ruling that a hot dog is not a sandwich?

There's depth. And then there's in-depth.

To get beyond the news and receive actionable intelligence about this topic or thousands more, simply enter your email address below.

You May Also Like

All quiet on the Western Front as Biden’s calls for unity fall on woke ears

A president, a poet and a country music star preach unity in inauguration